Shoemaker and Russo discuss three framing traps that may distort our decisions. The ability to frame a situation, scenario, or a problem set is vital to the decision-making process. It provides a “stable, coherent cognitive structure that organizes and simplifies the complex reality that a manager operates in.” (Hoch, Kunreuther, and Gunther, 2001). There are three types of frames: problem frames, decision frames, and thinking frames. These frames provide a mental image of the situation or issue at hand, but individuals can fall into traps that distort the real picture. Also, frame blindness can complicate a situation even further as all too often leaders and managers view and operate through the view or lenses of one particular viewpoint. These traps include frame blindness, the illusion of completeness, and overconfidence.
Discuss three ways you can avoid "framing traps" and provide a detailed example of each from your life experience. Could you have framed each situation differently? What did the exercise teach you about complex decision-making? What additional tools or "frames" might have helped you through the process? How was "risk" a factor in your examples? What did you learn about yourself through this exercise?
The framing trap refers to the tendency of decision makers to be influenced by the way that a situation or problem is presented. In my role as a leader, I'm mindful of the way I present and handle conflict resolution. My job is to help my departments excel at customer satisfaction and customer retention. This week's assignment was somewhat of a challenge because it drew my attention to past mistakes I've made in leadership. In my experience I've learned that it'a vital in order to avoid the traps that come with frames, leaders should consider the following:
Always try to reframe the problem in various ways and look for distortions caused by the frames.
Try posing problems in a neutral, redundant way that combines gains and losses or embraces different reference points.
When others recommend decisions, examine the way they framed the problem and challenge them with different frames.
An example when my framing lacked objective was when I had an opportunity to mentor two interns to shadow me during the summer. Initially, I was not too fond of the idea due to my travel schedule. The way the plan was presented to me appeared as if I would have to spoon feed them tons of information on how to be an effective leader. The mere fact that I was elected to do this task was both exciting and dreadful at the same time. However, when I met with the interns and asked them what did they expect to learn, I was shocked at their responses. They explained their experiences with other directors and felt as if they were being too "corporate." They were looking for an authentic experience by way of hands-on rather than haring cookie-cutter speeches to impress them. Had I not reframed the way I looked at mentoring, my vision would have remained distorted. Have you ever dreaded having to take on a task only to find it rewarding once you changed your approach to the situation?
Another example of a framing traps I experienced was early on in my career came when I was employed in oil and gas. I was stuck on a certain way a process flow value should be opened to prevent a rush of fluid into a distillation tower. I believed opening the valve slowly over an 8-hour time frame would be the best method to keep to avoid a tower swing. It was not until I became open minded to positively framing my thought process, that I came into the realization that my way of doing the job was not the only way nor the best way. I had to become vulnerable ( take risks) to others to understand that change is necessary to accomplish specific outcomes.
The third example of a framing tramp I experienced has been in my personal life. A year after Hurricane Harvey mold was found in my mother's home. If you have ever dealt with construction project managers, then you can imagine the problems we encountered in agreed on the "how to" repair the home. Although I do not know how to build a house, I did know how to read the Scope of the Work contract. The builder would suggest one thing and explain why his way of doing things his idea would work better. I would then come back and tell that I disagreed because he was negatively thinking of workload. After days of going back and forth about the changes I wanted to be made, the builder realized that my idea was not only better but more economically feasible. It was through my challenging of him to reframe the way he looked upon a perceived problem that did not exist.
Finally, I am of the mindset that we must continuously create new frames for each unique situation we may find ourselves in. Avoiding the unknown by staying in our safe and comfortable known frame leads to frame blindness and makes your decisions obtuse and inadequate for the ever-changing world.
This exercise has taught me to be balanced, well-rounded in my decision-making process and that there is no one answer for complex situations or that a single frame will address an issue. As a leader, the best thing that I can do is cultivate an environment in which promotes a vision, critical thinking, collaboration, strategic problems solving and teamwork. The executive leaders in my organization should empower the individuals that we lead, to generate new ideas and challenge the usual way of doing business. Today’s environment is continually changing, and we must do the same to stay competitive, relevant and thriving for years to come.
Reference:
Hoch, S., Kunreuther, H., & Gunther, R. (2001). Wharton on making decisions. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
Shoemaker, P. J., & Russo, J. E. (2001). Managing Frames to Make Better Decisions. In S. J. Hoch, H. C. Kunreuther, & R. E. Gunther, Wharton on Making Decisions (pp. 131 - 158). Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons.


No comments:
Post a Comment